To redo a website without breaking anything, follow eight steps in order: audit what exists, set goals, draw the site structure, prepare 301 redirects, write the content, design, build and test, then launch and monitor. The classic trap is to start with the design. The real risks almost always hide in old addresses, forgotten content and rushed testing.
Step 1: what should you audit before touching anything?
Before you delete anything, take stock of what exists. You need to know what your site already does well, so you do not lose it.
- Content: list every page in a table, with its address, title and role.
- Visit statistics: which pages get the most visitors, where do they come from, what do they do next?
- The pages that bring contacts, orders or appointment requests.
- The pages that show up in search results, and for which words.
- Lighthouse measurements, Google’s free audit tool: performance, accessibility, best practices. Write down the results before the redesign so you can compare afterwards.
- Known problems: slow pages, broken links, poor display on mobile, forms that do not work.
For each page, decide: keep as it is, improve, merge with another, or delete. This list will serve you in every following step.
Step 2: how do you set useful goals?
A redesign without a goal is just a change of scenery. Write in a few lines what the new site must do better than the old one.
- More contact requests or appointments.
- Easier reading on mobile.
- A faster site.
- A version people can use with a screen reader or a keyboard.
- One or more extra languages.
- A site your team can update on its own.
Pick two or three numbers to follow in your statistics, for example the number of requests sent through the form. You will then judge the redesign on facts, not on impressions.
Step 3: why is the site structure worth the effort?
The site structure is the map of your website: which pages, grouped under which sections. Prepare it on paper or in a spreadsheet, before any drawing.
- Start from what your visitors are looking for, not from your company’s org chart.
- Keep few main sections, with names everyone understands.
- Every page should be reachable in a few clicks from the home page.
- Give each page a clear, stable address. Avoid changing it without reason: every changed address is a page to redirect.
- If the site is multilingual, decide whether all languages share the same structure.
Step 4: how do you keep your search visibility with 301 redirects?
This is the step people forget most often, and the one that does the most damage. If a page changes address without a redirect, visitors and search engines land on a 404 error, and visibility built over years can disappear.
A 301 redirect tells the browser and search engines: “this page has moved for good, here is its new address”. Here is how to go about it.
- Take the list from step 1 and add a “new address” column.
- Redirect each old page to the closest page by topic, not all of them to the home page.
- If a page disappears with no equivalent, redirect to the most logical section, or show a real, helpful error page.
- Think about old addresses of images, PDF documents and language versions.
- Keep the titles and descriptions of pages that perform well, as long as they remain accurate.
- Prepare the redirect file before launch, not after.
Every old address without a redirect is a door you wall up without telling anyone.
Step 5: who writes the content, and when?
Texts and images are the number one cause of delays. Start preparing them at the same time as the structure, without waiting for the design. A pretty template filled with placeholder text warps as soon as the real text arrives.
- Reuse the good existing texts, and rewrite the vague or outdated ones.
- Write for the person reading on a phone: short sentences, clear headings, one idea per paragraph.
- Plan translations and proofreading by someone who truly speaks the language.
- Add alternative text to useful images: it helps accessibility and understanding.
- Compress photos before uploading them. They often account for half of a page’s weight.
Step 6: how do you approach design and prototypes?
Only now do you draw. Start with simple mock-ups of the main pages: home, a content page, an action page such as contact or shop. Validate the structure before polishing colours and details.
- Design for mobile first, then scale up to desktop.
- Choose strong enough colour contrasts and large enough text for everyone to read.
- Use a clickable prototype to test the journey with three or four people around you who do not know the project.
- Limit the number of fonts and styles: a consistent site is faster to build and easier to read.
- Keep your brand identity, unless the redesign exists precisely to change it.
Step 7: what should you test before launch?
Have the new site built on a non-public test address, then check it seriously. Also ask the development team to block indexing of that version, so it does not appear in search engines.
- Mobile: test on real phones, not only by shrinking the computer window.
- Browsers: open the site in at least two or three different browsers.
- Accessibility: go through the site with the keyboard only, and check contrasts and alternative texts.
- Speed: run Lighthouse again and compare with the measurements from step 1.
- Forms, shop, booking: do a complete test from start to finish.
- Links: look for broken links and check the 301 redirects one by one.
- Languages: proofread each version and check that the language switcher leads to the right page.
- Data: check that visit statistics are properly installed on the new site.
Step 8: how do you handle launch and follow-up?
Pick a quiet moment to go live, not the eve of an important campaign. Keep a full copy of the old site so you can go back if a serious problem appears.
- Switch on the 301 redirects at the same time as the new site.
- Remove the indexing block used during testing.
- Immediately retest the key pages, the forms and the redirects.
- Watch your statistics and 404 errors every day for the first weeks.
- Fix quickly: a forgotten link takes minutes to repair.
- Plan a review after a few months: have the goals from step 2 been reached?
It is normal for traffic to move a little after a redesign. If you followed the steps properly, it settles afterwards. If some pages lose visitors for good, go back to your audit list to understand what changed.
To measure where your site stands, compare it with Toprova’s rankings. Every site is scored out of 10 there: 80% by a jury (design 40%, usability 30%, creativity 20%, content 10%) and 20% by three Lighthouse measurements. Only sites that reach 7.0 out of 10 are published. Redesign finished? Submit it to Toprova for CHF 9.90.