A good website can be understood in five seconds, is easy to read, works as well on a phone as on a computer, loads fast and can be used by everyone. Here are the ten criteria a demanding jury really looks at. For each one you will find why it matters and how to check it yourself, without any complicated tools.

How does Toprova score a website?

Every site gets a score out of 10. It is 80% the jury’s judgement: design 40%, usability 30%, creativity 20%, content 10%. The remaining 20% comes from three Lighthouse measurements: performance, accessibility and best practices. Below 7.0 out of 10, a site is not published. The ten criteria below cover exactly these two sides: what a person sees and what a machine measures.

1. The message is clear in five seconds

A visitor arrives, looks at the screen and decides in a moment whether to stay. If the page does not say clearly who you are, what you offer and what they can do next, they leave.

How to check: show your home page to someone for five seconds, then hide the screen. Ask what your business does. If the answer is vague, rework the headline and the first sentence.

2. The hierarchy guides the eye

Not everything can be important at once. A good site has one main element per screen, then secondary elements, then the detail. When everything shouts, nothing gets read.

How to check: squint at your page until the text blurs. What stays visible is what visitors will see first. Is it what you wanted?

3. The typography is readable

Text is the main material of a website. Type that is too small, lines that are too long or tight line spacing tire the reader quickly.

  • Body text of at least 16 px on mobile.
  • Lines of roughly 60 to 75 characters.
  • Generous line spacing, around 1.5.
  • Two typefaces at most, with clear roles.

4. The contrast is sufficient

Light grey on white looks elegant on a designer’s screen and is unreadable in sunlight. Contrast concerns everyone, not only people with low vision.

How to check: Chrome’s developer tools show the contrast ratio of a colour. For normal text, aim for at least 4.5 to 1, the threshold in the WCAG accessibility rules. Also test with your screen brightness turned right down.

5. The navigation is obvious

Visitors must know where they are, where they can go and how to get back. Precise labels beat trendy words. “Our prices” is clearer than “Discover”.

How to check: give a friend a task, for example “find out how to contact me”. Watch without speaking. Count the hesitations. Every hesitation is a navigation flaw.

6. The mobile version is designed, not just shrunk

On a phone, a site that simply shrinks disappoints. Buttons must be big enough for a thumb, the menu easy to open, and nothing should spill off the screen.

  • Tap targets of about 44 px on each side, with space between them.
  • No horizontal scrolling.
  • Suitable forms: the right keyboard opens for an email or a number.

How to check: open your site on your own phone and, if you have one, on an older second phone.

7. The site is fast

A slow page feels careless, even when it is beautiful. Oversized images are the most common cause.

How to check: Lighthouse is built into Chrome, in the developer tools. Run it on your home page and look at the performance score. Compress images, use modern formats and load off-screen images later.

8. The site is accessible

An accessible site can be used with a keyboard alone, a screen reader or heavy zoom. It is a sign of quality, and it also helps search engines understand your page.

  • Every meaningful image has alternative text.
  • Every form field has a visible label.
  • Keyboard focus is visible on every element.
  • Headings follow a logical order: one h1, then h2s.

How to check: press the Tab key and go through the whole page without a mouse. Then zoom to 200%.

9. The content is useful

A beautiful empty site stays empty. The jury checks whether the text answers the real questions: price, timing, service area, contact, proof of reliability. Write for one specific person, not for “everyone”.

How to check: list the five questions customers ask you most often. Does each one have an answer visible within two clicks?

10. The details are cared for

This is often what separates a good site from a very good one. Button states on hover and click, clear error messages, forms that keep what was typed, a useful 404 page, a confirmation after sending.

How to check: make mistakes on purpose. Leave a field empty, enter a fake email, type an address that does not exist. Does the site help you fix it, or leave you on your own?

A good website goes unnoticed: you find what you came for, and you leave feeling that someone took care of you.

What next?

Go through these ten points with fresh eyes, ideally with someone who does not know your business. Fix the three weakest first. Then compare your site with the Toprova rankings to see what the best ones do. If you think your site deserves a place there, you can submit it for CHF 9.90: it will be reviewed with the same method as every other site.