At Toprova, every site goes first to three AI agents, then to three human jurors. Only the jurors’ scores count. We are often asked why we keep both. Here is the answer.
What the agents do
The three agents each work on their own. The Art Direction Agent runs on Claude Opus 5.5, the Usability Agent on Claude Sonnet 5.5, the Creative Agent on Claude Fable 5.2. Three different models, three different angles.
They see the same anonymised screenshots. The site is called S01 or S02, never by its name. No agent sees the others’ scores. The result is a written pre-analysis that goes to the jurors. It notes what works, what jars, and which questions to check on the real site.
What they cannot see
An agent only sees still images. It misses a good part of what makes a website:
- animations, transitions and their rhythm;
- real hovering, clicking and scrolling;
- moving from page to page, menus, forms;
- the feeling of speed, or sluggishness, when you use the site.
The first session made this very clear. Out of 16 sites, the agents could not judge 8 from the screenshots. Four were stuck on a 3D loading screen, two returned an anti-bot page and two were too slow for the capture. A person who opens the site waits, clicks and sees what is really there.
Why we keep them anyway
- Nothing gets forgotten. The pre-analysis goes through the same points for every site. The juror has a checklist in front of them, even at the end of a long day.
- Support for independence. The agents know neither the site’s name nor the studio behind it. Their reading is not swayed by reputation. The juror can test it against their own impression.
- Cross-checking. When the three agents disagree, that is a signal. The juror knows where to look more closely.
The human decides
The jurors read the pre-analysis, then open the real site and score design, usability, creativity and content by eye. Their scores replace the pre-analysis; they are not added to it. If an agent got something wrong, its mistake has no effect on the score.
AI is a good reading assistant. It is not a juror.