Toprova rewards the best websites. For the result to mean anything, every site goes through the same method. No shortcuts, no paid placements. Here is how it works, from the first test to publication.

A score out of 10, in two parts

A site’s final score is calculated like this: 80 % comes from the jury, 20 % from automated measurements. The jury therefore weighs four times as much as the machine. That is deliberate. A site can be very fast and still say nothing to anyone. The measurements act as a safety rail, not as a judge.

Below 7.0 out of 10, a site does not appear on Toprova. The threshold is the same for everyone.

Step 1: the measurements

Toprova runs Lighthouse, Google’s auditing tool, with the desktop profile. We run it three times and keep the median, so that one unusually slow or fast run does not skew the result. Three scores out of 100 are used:

  • speed, meaning Lighthouse’s performance score;
  • accessibility;
  • best practices.

We average the three and bring the result down to a score out of 10. That is the “measurements” part of the score.

Step 2: a pre-analysis by three AI agents

Next, three independent AI agents examine the site. The Art Direction Agent runs on Claude Opus 5.5, the Usability Agent on Claude Sonnet 5.5 and the Creative Agent on Claude Fable 5.2. They all see the same anonymised screenshots: the site is called S01, S02 and so on. No agent knows the site’s name or what the other two think.

This pre-analysis does not count towards the score. Its only job is to prepare the jurors’ work.

Steps 3 and 4: three jurors decide, then we publish

Three human jurors read the pre-analysis, then open the real site. They navigate, click, scroll and score by eye. Only their scores count, and they replace the pre-analysis entirely. Each juror rates four criteria from 1 to 10:

  • design: 40 %;
  • usability: 30 %;
  • creativity: 20 %;
  • content: 10 %.

The scores then go through a Bayesian average. In practice, we add 3 “reference” votes of 6.5. A site rated by only a few jurors therefore stays close to 6.5. It cannot overtake a site rated by many jurors on the strength of two or three enthusiastic opinions. Once the score is set, the site is published with the Toprova stamp.

The rules that never change

  • Nobody buys their place. Submitting a site costs CHF 9.90 in review fees. The fee is not refunded if the site is turned down, and it does not raise the score.
  • A juror never rates a site made by their own studio or for one of their clients.
  • The publisher of Toprova may appear in the ranking; its websites are rated blind by the same jury, without exception.
  • The public rating, given by registered accounts from 1 to 10, is shown separately. It never counts towards the score.
The machine measures, the AI prepares, the human decides.